Propertypulse
real estateTelegram

Appraisers Warn Off-Market Sales Are Clouding Home Valuations

Appraisals·October 24, 2026

Appraisers are sounding an alarm about a shift that is changing how homes get valued. A growing share of properties are sold without ever appearing on public listing sites, and some are marketed with interiors that buyers and appraisers cannot see in advance. For the people whose job is to put a number on a house, both trends make the work harder.

The core problem is comparable sales, or "comps." Appraisers build a valuation by finding recent sales of similar homes nearby and adjusting for differences in size, condition and features. When a sale never reaches the multiple listing service or another public feed, the appraiser may not know it happened, or may not be able to confirm the price, terms or condition of the property. Hidden interiors add another layer of uncertainty, since an appraiser cannot always verify finishes, layout or updates that would normally inform the adjustments.

Those gaps translate into time. Verifying a comp that is not in standard records can mean extra calls, document requests and, in some cases, a physical inspection, all of which stretch the schedule. Appraisers expect turnaround times to lengthen as a result, which can push back closings and refinances that depend on a timely valuation.

For buyers, sellers and agents, the practical takeaway is to build in more lead time. Off-market transactions may draw closer scrutiny from lenders, so sharing sale details and documentation early could help keep a deal on track. Whether the trend keeps growing will depend on how much of the market moves off-platform, but for now appraisers are signaling that both the workload and the wait are going up.

Reporting based on an external source.