Fifth Circuit Weighs Whether FinCEN's Property Rule Stays Dead
Regulation·November 14, 2026
The fight over a federal anti-money laundering rule for home sales has moved to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, and two title industry trade groups have now weighed in. The American Land Title Association and the Texas Land Title Association each filed amicus, or friend-of-the-court, briefs as the appeal proceeds. The central question is whether a lower court's March decision to vacate the rule should stand.
The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, known as FinCEN, wrote the rule to bring more visibility to residential purchases made without a mortgage. These are deals where a buyer pays in full, often through an LLC, trust or other entity, and no lender is involved. Regulators have long worried that such structures can obscure who really owns a property and where the money came from. Under the rule, certain of these transfers would have had to be reported to the government by the professionals who handle closings.
In East Texas, a federal judge sided with the challengers and vacated the rule in March. A vacatur sets a rule aside entirely, so the question now is whether the appeals court will reinstate it or leave the lower court's ruling in place. Nothing about the outcome is settled, and the court's decision could come down either way.
The title groups have a direct stake in that answer. Title companies and settlement agents would be the ones collecting information and filing reports, so the practical burden of the rule falls squarely on their members. Trade association briefs in cases like this typically focus on how a rule would operate day to day, what it would cost to comply with, and whether the agency followed the proper process when it adopted the rule. The groups' filings are a reminder that the people who would carry out the requirement are paying close attention to the litigation.
The outcome will matter well beyond Texas. Closing agents in every state handle cash-heavy transactions, and a Fifth Circuit ruling would shape how federal courts in its region treat the rule. For now, buyers, sellers and closing professionals should not assume the reporting requirement is either in force or gone for good. Anyone with a pending all-cash purchase or a transfer into an entity should check with counsel or their title company before closing.
Reporting based on an external source.