From 401(k) to 23 Rentals: How One Louisville Investor Did It
Investing·November 1, 2026
Nathan Nicholson, a full-time sales professional in Louisville, Kentucky, has built a portfolio of 23 single-family rental homes, and he did it by cashing out his 401(k). Eleven of those properties are now paid off, a milestone that matters a great deal to the bottom line because it removes the mortgage payment entirely.
The portfolio generates about $311,000 a year in rent. The profile puts his true annual net, the figure that remains once the costs of running the properties are accounted for, at roughly $112,000. That gap between gross rent and what an owner actually keeps is the number investors should focus on before copying a strategy like this one. Rent is only the starting point. Property taxes, insurance, repairs, vacancies and financing all take a share, and the spread between the two figures tells you how much of the rent is really available to spend or reinvest.
Using retirement savings to buy property deserves a careful look. Withdrawing money from a 401(k) before retirement age typically triggers income tax on the amount taken out and, in most cases, an additional 10 percent early withdrawal penalty, although some exceptions apply. Those costs reduce the amount that actually gets invested, so anyone weighing a similar move needs to count them before the first purchase, not after.
Nicholson's results show what a steady, long-running approach to rentals can produce, and the eleven debt-free homes illustrate how the strategy can compound over time. A single success story is not a forecast, though. Local rent levels, interest rates and maintenance costs vary widely, and a plan that works in one market can strain in another. Anyone considering a similar path should run their own numbers and speak with a tax professional before touching retirement accounts.
Reporting based on an external source.