Nantucket Brokerage Must Pay $1.3 Million Over Home Expansion Claim
Legal·November 17, 2026
A Nantucket brokerage has been ordered to pay $1.3 million to a couple who bought a two-bedroom house on the island expecting to enlarge it, only to learn the property could not be expanded the way they had planned.
Mary Murray and Jeffrey Ment purchased the home after their real estate agent told them they could add on to it. That assurance turned out to be wrong. For buyers, the gap between the house they bought and the house they wanted is the heart of the dispute: a renovation that was central to their decision was never something the property could deliver.
The case is a reminder of how much weight buyers place on an agent's statements about zoning, building limits and future use. On a market like Nantucket, where lot sizes are limited and local rules on construction and setbacks can be strict, a claim about adding square footage is not a small detail. Buyers often rely on it when deciding how much to pay and whether a home fits their plans for years to come.
Agents are generally expected to verify what they tell clients, or to clearly say when a statement is unconfirmed. Buyers are usually advised to check permitted uses with the town and to get written confirmation of anything that affects the home's value. This case shows what can go wrong when that verification step is skipped and the buyer takes the agent's word on a point that matters.
The $1.3 million figure signals how seriously the outcome was treated, and it should prompt both buyers and brokerages to review how property features and expansion potential are described during a sale. Terms of any payment, appeal, or further action were not detailed in the source material.
Reporting based on an external source.